Barney's Replacement (TAGS Episode)

Episode Info

Barney's Replacement

• S2.E2
• Filmed: 33
• Aired: 34
• Original Air Date: 1961/10/09
• Writer(s): Jack Elinson and Charles Stewart
• Director: Bob Sweeney

Plot Summary

Barney's pride gets the best of him when Bob Rogers, a booksmart rookie from the state attorney's office, is sent to Mayberry to get law enforcement experience. Convinced Andy is out to replace him, Barney beats him to the punch and resigns to enter the business world as a door-to-door Miracle Sweep vacuum salesman. Andy tricks Barney into rejoining the force by showing him that Rogers does not have the mettle for the job.

Summary

Deputy Barney Fife's deep-seated insecurities come to the forefront when a young and highly skilled lawman, Bob Rogers, arrives in Mayberry. Rogers, an eager and capable officer from the state attorney's office, has been assigned to observe small-town law enforcement in action. From the moment he arrives, it becomes clear that he is not only knowledgeable but also exceptionally competent—displaying impressive marksmanship, a keen understanding of legal procedures, and an overall confidence that starkly contrasts with Barney’s more bumbling approach to police work.

At first, Andy Taylor, the ever-patient and wise sheriff, is pleased to have Rogers around and appreciates his enthusiasm. However, Barney quickly grows paranoid, convinced that Andy is grooming Rogers to take his place as deputy. His self-doubt spirals out of control as he misinterprets Andy’s praise of Rogers as evidence of an impending dismissal. Unable to bear the thought of being replaced, Barney impulsively quits his job, resigning as deputy in a huff.

In an effort to find a new career, Barney takes up a job as a door-to-door vacuum cleaner salesman, though, unsurprisingly, he struggles in this new role. Meanwhile, Andy realizes he must step in and help Barney see that he is not only valued but also irreplaceable in his own unique way. Wanting to restore Barney’s confidence, Andy orchestrates a situation that proves how important Barney is to the town.

Through a clever setup, Andy allows Barney to step in and "save the day," reminding everyone—especially Barney himself—that while he may not have the sharpest skills or the flashiest techniques, he brings a kind of dedication, heart, and local knowledge that cannot be easily replaced. Reassured of his importance, Barney returns to his position with renewed confidence, and all is right once again in Mayberry.

The episode highlights a recurring theme in the series: Barney’s deep-seated insecurities and Andy’s gentle, yet effective, way of reassuring him. It also underscores the show's core message—that people are valuable not just for their skills but for who they are and what they bring to their community.

Odd Facts Known by Few

• In the first wanted poster scene, in frustration, Barney files a poster of a criminal that had already been caught. In the next scene, when the temporary deputy is at the wanted poster board, the previously filed poster is back in its original spot on the board.

• Although Barney gets mad and resigns from the force several times before he finally resigns and moves to Raleigh after the fifth season, this is the only time Barney ever spends any real time away from the force. He would later try and resign in Citizen's Arrest.

• Barney mentions that he and Thelma Lou will be getting hitched soon. Although this never came to pass until the "Return to Mayberry" movie, it's notable that the writers had their union in mind early in the series.

• When Barney is writing out a ticket for Bob Rogers for illegal parking, after telling him that he was just trying to teach him a lesson, he tears up the ticket & throws it on the ground. A definite case of littering.

• Even though Barney refers to Deputy Bob as "son", and is constantly condescending to him as a rookie, the actor who portrayed Bob is only one year younger than Don Knotts.

• On Barney's first attempt at selling sweepers, he walks up on Clara's porch. From beside the vantage point of the filming camera, we can see the lighting department is a little late, and you can see that someone with a handheld light reflector begins to aim some sunlight onto Clara's porch which is just a little too shady. Watch the front door as soon as Barney gets on the porch. The reflected light begins on the door and once they discover the aim is off, they pan it to the left until it shines on Barney.

• When the car siren won't turn off and they are all looking under the hood. The larger black lady is standing watching, her paper bag says "Hollywood.” It’s only for a few moments.

• The license plate DC 269 is seen in the final scene on the front of Bob's car when Barney writes him a parking ticket. This plate was on the squad car in several episodes and on Roger Courtney's car in "The Clubmen" episode.

• Bob Rogers, from the State Attorney's Office, is explaining the "Green River Ordinance" to Andy. Although he says it was enacted in 1924, it was actually enacted on November 16, 1931. The Town of Green River, Wyoming (with a population of a little more than 3,000) deemed that "an emergency exists" and passed and approved Ordinance 175 that prohibits door-to-door selling. William Evers was Mayor at the time. Under this Ordinance, a salesman must be "invited" into the home of a resident before he can knock on the door in an attempt to peddle his wares.

• Andy parks the squad car in front of a fire hydrant just before he and Officer Bob Rogers talk about the Green River Ordinance.

• The fire hydrant in front of the courthouse keeps changing locations. Early in the show, it is a few feet away from the pole with the white stripes. Later, it appears to be right behind the pole. In the last scene, it appears to have disappeared altogether.

• In an odd string of coincidences, actor Mark Miller (Bob Rogers) played the role of "Roger" in a 1959 episode of "The Twilight Zone" entitled "I Dream of Genie", which starred later TAGS actor and director Howard Morris. Later, he guest starred as "Wild Bill Barrows" in the television show "I Dream of Jeannie" in a 1965 episode entitled "Ride 'Em Astronaut".

.

Memorable Quotes

Andy: All ready for school, are ya?

Opie: Yes.

Andy: Well, do a good day's work and act like somebody!

Character List

• Andy Griffith - Andy Taylor
• Don Knotts - Barney Fife
• Ronny Howard - Opie Taylor
• Mark Miller - Bob Rogers
• Cheerio Meredith - Emma Brand
• Hope Summers - Clara
• Betty Lynn - Thelma Lou